Peer Evaluation Form

Questionnaire

Does the manuscript contain new and significant information to justify publication?*

•  Yes
•  No
•  Not Applicable

•  Yes
•  No
•  Not Applicable

•  Yes
•  No
•  Not Applicable

•  Yes
•  No
•  Not Applicable

•  Yes
•  No
•  Not Applicable

•  Yes
•  No
•  Not Applicable

•  Yes
•  No
•  Not Applicable

Manuscript Structure

Length of article is:*

•  Too Short
•  Adequate
•  Too Long

•  Too Short
•  Adequate
•  Too Long

•  Too Short
•  Adequate
•  Too Long

Rating

Interest*

•  Accept
•  Minor Revision
•  Major Revision
•  Reject

•  Yes
•  No

In line with Open Science, we ask reviewers if they agree with the publication of their approval review reports for the manuscript, according to the following options:

•  Yes, I agree to publish the review with my identification.
•  Yes, I agree to publish the review without my identification.

Comments

Comments to the Author

Confidential Comments to the Editor